Cookie exchange
Cookie exchange planner
At a cookie exchange (or cookie swap), each guest bakes about half a dozen cookies for every person attending: with 8 people, everyone bakes 4 dozen and goes home with 4 dozen of mixed cookies. Say how many are baking and the planner gives the dozens, a sign-up sheet of who bakes what and the ingredients to buy.
Your cookie exchange
- Bakers
- 8
- Each bakes
- 4 dozen
- Each takes home
- 4 dozen
- Batches each
- 2 of 36 cookies
Each baker makes 48 cookies of one kind. The ingredients below are for 2 batches of a classic chocolate chip cookie that makes 36.
Who bakes what
8 items
Baking aisle
9 items
Dairy and eggs
2 items
Also on the list
The printout lists the items; the amounts are in the app.
How to host a cookie exchange
- Pick the guest list: eight is close to ideal, and most hosts stop at 10 or 12. Fewer bakers means fewer dozens each.
- Send the invites at least 10 days ahead: with the date, the rule (how many dozen each), and a request to name the cookie when they reply.
- Pass round the sign-up sheet: one line per baker and one kind of cookie per line, so no two people bake the same thing.
- On the day: a card in front of each batch with the recipe name and who baked it, plus any allergens, and boxes or bags for taking cookies home.
- The swap: everyone walks round the table and fills a tin, or picks up ready-made bags of four to six of each kind.
Cookie exchange rules
Most swaps keep a few house rules, and saying them in the invite saves awkward moments later:
- Homemade only. A common rule is that every cookie is baked from scratch, so the trade stays fair.
- One kind per baker, claimed on the sign-up sheet, first come first served.
- The same count for everyone, by the rule you pick above: half a dozen for every person attending, or a dozen for each other guest plus one to share.
- Cookies that travel: sturdy drop cookies, shortbread and bars hold up in a tin better than anything with soft frosting.
- Bring the recipe: a printed card or a link, so a favourite can be baked again.
Dozens per baker for 4 to 12 bakers
| Bakers | Half a dozen each | A dozen each, plus one |
|---|---|---|
| 4 | 2 dozen | 4 dozen |
| 6 | 3 dozen | 6 dozen |
| 8 | 4 dozen | 8 dozen |
| 10 | 5 dozen | 10 dozen |
| 12 | 6 dozen | 12 dozen |
The ingredients come from King Arthur Baking's classic chocolate chip cookie, which makes 36 cookies, three dozen, a batch. Baking something else? Paste your recipe into the recipe scaler and scale it to your dozens. Hosting a full dinner instead? Try the potluck planner or the Christmas dinner planner.
Questions people ask
How many cookies per person for a cookie exchange?
Two common rules. Betty Crocker asks each guest to bake about half a dozen cookies for every person attending, so with eight people, everyone bakes four dozen. SignUp.com asks for a dozen for each other guest, plus an extra dozen to share at the party. King Arthur Baking says bakers commonly bring two to four dozen.
How many people should I invite?
Mashed finds most hosts cap it at 10 or 12, and says eight is close to ideal; SignUp.com says keep it to 10 guests or fewer. King Arthur Baking caps a home swap at a baker's dozen, and says four to six guests work too.
Is there a limit on how many dozen to ask for?
Mashed quotes Paperless Post: six dozen is a good maximum to ask of each baker, whatever the guest count. With the dozen rule and 10 bakers, everyone bakes 10 dozen, which is a lot; switch to the half-dozen rule or invite fewer people.
Cookie exchange or cookie swap: what's the difference?
None: they are two names for the same party. Each guest bakes a big batch of one kind of cookie, everyone trades, and everyone goes home with a mix.
How far ahead should I send the invites?
At least 10 days ahead, says SignUp.com, so nobody hears about a few dozen cookies at the last minute. Ask each baker to name their cookie when they reply, so no two bake the same one.
How should guests bring the cookies?
Packed in a tin or a box, or already split into bags of four to six, as King Arthur Baking suggests for a quick swap. Put a card in front of each batch with the recipe name and who baked it.
Where the numbers come from
The dozens come from published cookie exchange guides; the ingredients from a baking company's published recipe.
Shopping for your batch?
In Erlist your household sees the same list, live, on their own phones. Put your cookie's ingredients on it, split the shopping and tick things off as you go.
For iPhone.